NewsThe IslanderJune 23, 2026Manatee
Holmes Beach residents and officials oppose Second Avenue traffic changes
City officials and residents are pushing back against a proposal to restrict southbound traffic on Second Avenue in Holmes Beach. The plan, intended to reduce cut-through traffic, faces criticism for potentially increasing congestion on Gulf Drive and failing to address traffic issues on other city streets.
Read the full story at The IslanderWhy It Matters
The city commission is considering whether to implement measures or restrict vehicle flow on Second Avenue, which would directly impact commute routes and traffic patterns for local residents.
Key Facts
- City staff presented a proposal on May 26 to restrict southbound traffic on Second Avenue by installing landscape islands at 52nd Street.
- Alternative traffic-calming options include four-way stops at every intersection, a 15 mph speed limit, raised crosswalks, speed tables, and lane narrowing.
- Commissioner Steve Oelfke publicly withdrew his support for the southbound traffic restriction on June 9, citing concerns about increased congestion on Gulf Drive.
- Commissioner Terry Schaefer requested a comprehensive citywide traffic study rather than isolated street-by-street solutions.
- Residents expressed concerns that the proposal ignores similar traffic issues on other streets like 56th, 60th, and 63rd streets.
- Resident Alan Williams stated that high volumes of cut-through traffic on Second Avenue create safety issues and potential impacts on property values.
- A group of citizens supporting traffic changes is scheduled to present to the city commission on June 23.
Who's Mentioned
personSteve Oelfke“City Commissioner who withdrew his support for the traffic restriction proposal.”personTerry Schaefer“City Commissioner who proposed a citywide traffic study.”personJim Denny“Local resident who spoke in opposition to the proposal.”personAlan Williams“Local resident who supports traffic relief measures on Second Avenue.”locationGulf Drive“The major roadway that would likely see increased traffic if Second Avenue is re”locationSecond Avenue“The primary street subject to the proposed traffic changes.”locationHolmes Beach“The city where the traffic changes are proposed.”personNancy Deal“Local resident who argued that traffic issues are citywide and not limited to Se”